| 1925: E.H. (Ted) Braund/ Gil Forgue | 1926:-1933: ? | 1934: Jack Worden/ Ernie (Dinnie) Dinsmore | 1935: ? | 1936: Gil Forgue | 1937: Gil Forgue | 1938: Gil Forgue | 1939-1942: ? | 1943: Captain Chet Smith | 1944: Bill Farquharson/ Clare Van Horne |
| 1945: Bill Farquharson/ Clare Van Horne | 1946: Clare Van Horne | 1947: Clare Horne | 1948: Clare Van Horne | 1949: Clare Van Horne | 1950: Clare Van Horne | 1951: Clare Van Horne | 1952: Clare Van Horne | 1953: Clare Van Horne | 1954: Clare Van Horne |
| 1954-55: Frank Colman | 1956: Frank Colman | 1957: Frank Colman * Niagara League | 1958: Ray Yelle | 1959: Frank Colman | 1960: Ken McFadden | 1961: Norm Aldridge | 1962: Dave Taylor | 1963: Stan 'Gabby' Anderson | 1964: Tom Burgess |
| 1965: Tom Burgess | 1966: Russ Evon | 1967: Joe Nash | 1968: Ray Yelle | 1969: Roy McKay | 1970: Roy McKay | 1971: Roy McKay | 1972: Roy McKay | 1973: Ken Benjamin | 1974: Roy McKay |
| 1975: Roy McKay | 1976: Roy McKay | 1977: Reid Heffernan | 1978: Reid Heffernan | 1979: Reid Heffernan | 1980: Reid Heffernan | 1981: Roy McKay | 1982: Roy McKay | 1983: Roy McKay | 1984: Roy McKay |
| 1985: Roy McKay | 1986: Wayne Fenlon | 1987: Wayne Fenlon | 1988: Wayne Fenlon | 1989: Wayne Fenlon | 1990: Jim Detlor | 1991: Stan Slack | 1992: Stan Slack/ Jay Lapp | 1993: Graeme Nichol | 1994: Roy McKay |
| 1995: Roy McKay/ Alex McKay | 1996: Alex McKay | 1997: Arden Eddie | 1998: Arden Eddie/ Ken Frohwerk | 1999: Arden Eddie | 2000: Ron Leclair | 2001: Arden Eddie | 2002: Arden Eddie | 2003: Bob White | 2004: Ron Leclair |
| 2005: Harry Muir/ Ron LeClair/ Scott Gillespie/ Pete Babcock | 2006: Roop Chanderdat | 2007: Roop Chanderdat | 2008: Roop Chanderdat | 2009: Roop Chanderdat | 2010: Roop Chanderdat | 2011: Roop Chanderdat | 2012: Roop Chanderdat | 2013: Roop Chanderdat | 2014: Roop Chanderdat |
| 2015: Roop Chanderdat | 2016: Roop Chanderdat | 2017: Roop Chanderdat | 2018: Roop Chanderdat | 2019-2024: Roop Chanderdat |
